Witching Stave vs Gnarled Necromancer's Staff

Witching Stave
Binds when equipped
Two-HandStaff
55 - 83 DamageSpeed 3.60
(19.2 damage per second)
+6 Stamina
+8 Shadow Resistance
+5 Intellect
Requires Level 17
Equip: +27 Shadow Spell Damage
Sells for 28 Silver 22 Copper to vendors
Item Level 22
CHANGED Changed in Forever: stats.
Gnarled Necromancer's Staff
Binds when picked up
Two-HandStaff
45 - 69 DamageSpeed 2.80
(20.4 damage per second)
+10 Intellect
Sells for 9 Silver 95 Copper to vendors
Item Level 24
FOREVER New in World of Warcraft Forever: not in Classic Era.

Side by side:

Set your class weights in Preferences to see which is better for you.

Stat Witching Stave Gnarled Necromancer's Staff Δ
Item Level 22 24 +2
Required Level 17 −16
DPS 19.2 20.4 +1.2
Speed 3.60 2.80 −0.80
Damage 55 - 83 45 - 69
Int +5 +10 +5
Sta +6 −6
Shadow Dmg +27 −27
Shadow Res +8 −8
Total Stats 11 10 −1
Sell Price 28s 22c 9s 95c −18s 27c
Binding Binds when equipped Binds when picked up

Δ is Gnarled Necromancer's Staff minus Witching Stave: green where Gnarled Necromancer's Staff is better, red where it is worse (a lower required level is better; speed and sell price have no better side). Total Stats adds up Str, Agi, Sta, Int and Spi.

Compare with another item:

Or pick from a list: Compare Witching Stave with… · Compare Gnarled Necromancer's Staff with…