Caretaker's Cape vs Stalwart Cloak

Caretaker's Cape
Binds when picked up
BackCloth
45 Armor
+11 Stamina
+8 Spirit
Requires Level 58
Equip: +26 Healing
Equip: +9 Spell Damage
Sells for 1 Gold 70 Silver 98 Copper to vendors
Item Level 63
Stalwart Cloak
Binds when picked up
BackCloth
46 Armor
+14 Stamina
+80 Bonus Armor
Requires Level 60
Equip: +10 Hit Rating
Sells for 1 Gold 64 Silver 76 Copper to vendors
Item Level 65
FOREVER New in World of Warcraft Forever: not in Classic Era.

Side by side:

Set your class weights in Preferences to see which is better for you.

Stat Caretaker's Cape Stalwart Cloak Δ
Item Level 63 65 +2
Required Level 58 60 +2
Armor 45 46 +1
Sta +11 +14 +3
Spi +8 −8
Armor +80 +80
Heal +26 −26
Hit +10 +10
Spell Dmg +9 −9
Total Stats 19 14 −5
Sell Price 1g 70s 98c 1g 64s 76c −6s 22c
Binding Binds when picked up Binds when picked up

Δ is Stalwart Cloak minus Caretaker's Cape: green where Stalwart Cloak is better, red where it is worse (a lower required level is better; speed and sell price have no better side). Total Stats adds up Str, Agi, Sta, Int and Spi.

Compare with another item:

Or pick from a list: Compare Caretaker's Cape with… · Compare Stalwart Cloak with…