Cookie's Tenderizer vs Barbed Club

Cookie's Tenderizer
Binds when picked up
One-HandOne-Handed Mace
27 - 51 DamageSpeed 2.80
(13.9 damage per second)
+4 Strength
Requires Level 16
Chance on hit: Tenderize the target, increasing physical damage taken by 1 for 1 min.
Sells for 19 Silver 63 Copper to vendors
Item Level 21
CHANGED Changed in Forever: quality, stats, damage, effects.

Item page · change

Barbed Club
Binds when equipped
Main HandOne-Handed Mace
15 - 29 DamageSpeed 2.30
(9.6 damage per second)
Requires Level 14
Sells for 12 Silver 19 Copper to vendors
Item Level 19

Item page · change

Side by side:

Set your class weights in Preferences to see which is better for you.

Stat Cookie's Tenderizer Barbed Club Δ
Item Level 21 19 −2
Required Level 16 14 −2
DPS 13.9 9.6 −4.3
Speed 2.80 2.30 −0.50
Damage 27 - 51 15 - 29
Str +4 −4
Total Stats 4 −4
Sell Price 19s 63c 12s 19c −7s 44c
Binding Binds when picked up Binds when equipped

Δ is Barbed Club minus Cookie's Tenderizer: green where Barbed Club is better, red where it is worse (a lower required level is better; speed and sell price have no better side). Total Stats adds up Str, Agi, Sta, Int and Spi.

Compare with another item:

Or pick from a list: Compare Cookie's Tenderizer with… · Compare Barbed Club with…