Cookie's Tenderizer vs Sinslayer's Smasher

Cookie's Tenderizer

Binds when picked up

One-HandOne-Handed Mace

27 - 51 DamageSpeed 2.80

(13.9 damage per second)

+4 Strength

Requires Level 16

Chance on hit: Tenderize the target, increasing physical damage taken by 1 for 1 min.

Sells for 19 Silver 63 Copper to vendors

Item Level 21

CHANGED Changed in Forever: quality, stats, damage, effects.

Item page · change

Sinslayer's Smasher

Binds when equipped

One-HandOne-Handed Mace

16 - 31 DamageSpeed 2.60

(9.0 damage per second)

+2 Strength

Requires Level 13

Sells for 3 Copper to vendors

Item Level 18

FOREVER New in World of Warcraft Forever: not in Classic Era.

Item page · change

Side by side:

Set your class weights in Preferences to see which is better for you.

Stat	Cookie's Tenderizer	Sinslayer's Smasher	Δ
Item Level	21	18	−3
Required Level	16	13	−3
DPS	13.9	9.0	−4.9
Speed	2.80	2.60	−0.20
Damage	27 - 51	16 - 31
Str	+4	+2	−2
Total Stats	4	2	−2
Sell Price	19s 63c	3c	−19s 60c
Binding	Binds when picked up	Binds when equipped

Δ is Sinslayer's Smasher minus Cookie's Tenderizer: green where Sinslayer's Smasher is better, red where it is worse (a lower required level is better; speed and sell price have no better side). Total Stats adds up Str, Agi, Sta, Int and Spi.

Compare with another item:

Or pick from a list: Compare Cookie's Tenderizer with… · Compare Sinslayer's Smasher with…