Wicked Claw vs Magenta Dye

Wicked Claw
Sells for 5 Silver to vendors
Item Level 45

Item page · change

Magenta Dye
"Crafted by alchemists."
Sells for 2 Silver 50 Copper to vendors
Item Level 45
FOREVER New in World of Warcraft Forever: not in Classic Era.

Item page · change

Side by side:

Set your class weights in Preferences to see which is better for you.

Stat Wicked Claw Magenta Dye Δ
Item Level 45 45 0
Sell Price 5s 2s 50c −2s 50c

Δ is Magenta Dye minus Wicked Claw: green where Magenta Dye is better, red where it is worse (a lower required level is better; speed and sell price have no better side). Total Stats adds up Str, Agi, Sta, Int and Spi.

Compare with another item:

Or pick from a list: Compare Wicked Claw with… · Compare Magenta Dye with…