The best place to farm First Mate Hat is Stranglethorn Vale, where Bloodsail Elder Magus (level 44-45) drops it at 0.0%. That is the vanilla 1.12 chance, not yet confirmed in Forever. 7 sources are ranked below by drop chance.
Gold per kill: Bloodsail Elder Magus is worth about 14s 32c a kill in item drops (at Auction House prices). Gold farming spots, level 40-50
Best zones:

- Bloodsail Elder Magus 30.0, 89.5
- Bloodsail Sea Dog 29.9, 89.4
- Bloodsail Deckhand 30.0, 89.6
- Bloodsail Raider 27.5, 69.6
- Bloodsail Swabby 30.3, 89.8
- Bloodsail Mage 27.5, 69.6
- Bloodsail Warlock 23.9, 54.1
All sources, by drop chance:
| Source | Level | Zone | Spawns | Side | How | Drop% | Map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bloodsail Raider | 40-41 | Stranglethorn Vale | 18 | Drop | 0.0% | map | |
| Bloodsail Mage | 40-41 | Stranglethorn Vale | 12 | Drop | 0.0% | map | |
| Bloodsail Warlock | 42-43 | Stranglethorn Vale | 6 | Drop | 0.0% | map | |
| Bloodsail Sea Dog | 44-45 | Stranglethorn Vale | 41 | Drop | 0.0% | map | |
| Bloodsail Elder Magus | 44-45 | Stranglethorn Vale | 41 | Drop | 0.0% | map | |
| Bloodsail Deckhand | 43-44 | Stranglethorn Vale | 24 | Drop | 0.0% | map | |
| Bloodsail Swabby | 43-44 | Stranglethorn Vale | 14 | Drop | 0.0% | map |
Drop% is the rate recorded in Forever once a source has been looted ten times; a greyed figure is the vanilla 1.12 chance from the world data (classic data: from the patch 1.12 world data, not yet confirmed in forever). Spawns counts the source's spawn points in the world data. "Side" names which side can kill the NPC when the other finds it friendly. The lead picks the best chance among sources that are not a rare spawn and have at least three spawn points.