The best place to farm Fishbone Toothpick is Elwynn Forest, where Murloc Forager (level 9-10) can be pickpocketed for it at 16.7%. That is the vanilla 1.12 chance, not yet confirmed in Forever. 7 sources are ranked below by drop chance.
Best zones:
| Zone | Sources | Best source | Level | Drop% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elwynn Forest | 4 | Murloc Forager | 9-10 | 16.7% |
| Durotar | 1 | Makrura Shellhide | 6-7 | 16.7% |
| Tirisfal Glades | 2 | Vile Fin Minor Oracle | 8-9 | 11.1% |
- Murloc Forager 78.8, 45.0
- Murloc Lurker 78.3, 57.7
- Murloc 55.7, 66.7
- Murloc Streamrunner 51.4, 66.0
All sources, by drop chance:
| Source | Level | Zone | Spawns | Side | How | Drop% | Map |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Murloc Forager | 9-10 | Elwynn Forest | 60 | Pickpocket | 16.7% | map | |
| Murloc Lurker | 9-10 | Elwynn Forest | 44 | Pickpocket | 16.7% | map | |
| Makrura Shellhide | 6-7 | Durotar | 21 | Pickpocket | 16.7% | map | |
| Murloc | 6-7 | Elwynn Forest | 33 | Pickpocket | 13.0% | map | |
| Murloc Streamrunner | 6-7 | Elwynn Forest | 3 | Pickpocket | 12.5% | map | |
| Vile Fin Minor Oracle | 8-9 | Tirisfal Glades | 57 | Pickpocket | 11.1% | map | |
| Vile Fin Puddlejumper | 7-8 | Tirisfal Glades | 34 | Pickpocket | 7.5% | map |
Drop% is the rate recorded in Forever once a source has been looted ten times; a greyed figure is the vanilla 1.12 chance from the world data (vanilla reference — from the 1.12 world data, not yet confirmed in forever). Spawns counts the source's spawn points in the world data. "Side" names which side can kill the NPC when the other finds it friendly. The lead picks the best chance among sources that are not a rare spawn and have at least three spawn points.